Is magic permitted in Islam?

Is magic permitted in Islam? Does it replace Allah?
Also, if a man is succeptable to being hypnotized by magic. Who is to say that he was not under a magic spell from some evil Jinn the whole time?
What if the Quran was actually spoken while under this spell?
Would that explain why an illiterate tribal man spat out that garbled mess?
And if he could believe he was having sex with all of his wives, couldn't he be made to believe a Jinn was Allah?

Narrated Aisha: Magic was worked on Allah's Apostle so that he used to think that he had sexual relations with his wives while he actually had not. (Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 71, Number 660; see also Number 661)
Maybe the hadith relating that muhammad was imagining having sex with his wives — while in reality he had not — is a commentary/explanation to the first set of traditions? Note again that this tradition (originating with muhammad's favorite wife and sex partner!) also emphasizes that this happened not only once but regularly.
For a detailed discussion on the issue of magic and muhammad having come under a spell, see the articles listed in the dictionary entry muhammad and Satan.

Tammy Schaefer
T
1 following.
Release As Guest
30
30 ANSWER

Thats also called schizophrenia...imagining persons who really don't exist in the world.

Jeyaraj Cain
J

He was suicidal when he first "heard voices in his head".

Tammy Schaefer
T

He went to throw himself off of a cliff but "the angel Gabriel appeared and stopped him".

Tammy Schaefer
T

In 620 AD he had his "night of ascension" in which, he "rode a winged horse by the name of Buraq" to a mosque in Jerusalem (in 620 AD, there were no mosques in Jerusalem).

Tammy Schaefer
T

Doing magic is great sin in Islam. Magic or illusion is knowledge to harm people. It exists as there were magicians in court of Pharoah who spelled all people including Moses. Ropes were looked like moving snakes. When Moses did throw his stick and converted to real snake then all magicians became believers as they were expert and they knew Moses did not perform any magic. Similarly magicians tried to harm prophet muhammad and he became weak for a period but it didn't effect the revelations as it is protected by God Himself.
No majic or any knowledge can work without permission of God.
Prophet never tried to kill himself as it sin in Islam.

Muhammad Chaney
M

So Bukhari and Aisha are lying?

Tammy Schaefer
T

Buraq was not horse but a ride made of light and equal to horse in size. Prophet went to remainings of Solomon temple. In Islam any place of worship is mosque. Mosque is not a building.

Muhammad Chaney
M

People attributed false narrations to Prophet and Aisha are laying.

Muhammad Chaney
M

Really?? But King Solomons temple was levelled, to the ground in 685 BC... Mohammed claimes to have gone there in 620 AD.
So, again... İt is not possible.

Tammy Schaefer
T

It was leveled but the place was present which is known to Angel Gabriel.

Muhammad Chaney
M

I stood at al-Hijr, visualised Bayt al-Muqaddas and described its signs. Some of them said: How many doors are there in that mosque? I had not counted them so I began to look at it and counted them one by one and gave them information concerning them. (Ibn Sa'd, Kitab al-Tabaqat al-Kabir, Vol. 1,p. 248).

Tammy Schaefer
T

Check mate

Jim Ogden 3 years

Cheers mate

Tammy Schaefer 3 years

What "doors" did he count, in the rubble?

Tammy Schaefer
T

When he reached at that place God showed him Solomon temple in its original form and future events. All prophets who have died long ago came and offered prayer behind prophet. Then prophet moved to heavens.
All these events are done in few seconds as mentioned in hadith which proved prophet traveled out of time and space as he was moving in buraq or light.

Muhammad Chaney
M

such a fairy tale

Bablu Means 3 years

Bablu Means if today you can travel long distance in aeroplane then why God who created whole universe can send a ride made of light which can travel in speed of light.?

Muhammad Chaney 3 years

Faisal sahab choro religion k baatein... Congrats for that match... Njoy

Bablu Means 3 years

yeh wali topic palle nahi para... So can't give u d best response... Cz these stories seemed to me fictitious & man made ones. Right or wrong it does not hold water in many cases. Basically im a non believer. But there is sumthing supernatural i feel more often

Bablu Means 3 years

flight of imaginations... an example of Islamic Mythology

Anil Mccullough 3 years
20 view all comment Loading...

Or, he was hallucinating or, making up things which are later, clearly proven to be false.

Tammy Schaefer
T

Did he bring back any proof?

Tammy Schaefer
T

Tammy Schaefer, do you believe in the miracle birth of Christ, or the resurrection of Christ?

Ahmed Darden
A

Why wouldI? It is a neat and inspirational myth.. "the comforter comes to free man from the spectre and superstitions regarding death" but it is as believable as a flying horse.
Furthermore, the Christ story never had this hideous sado-sexual warning to women:

The Women of Hell Fire. Prophet
(saw) said: "O ALi, on the night of
my ascension (Miraj) I saw
women of my ummah who were
being severily punished that I
became concerned for them and
started cyring.
I saw a woman who had been
hung by her breast.
Then I saw a second woman who
was eating her own flesh and fire
raged below her.
A third woman was hanging by
her tongue and boiling water was
being poured down her throat.
A fourth was bent over, her hands
and feet were tied together, and
snakes and scorpions were
crawling all over her
A fifth was deaf, dumb, and blind,
enclosed in a cage of fire, her
brain oozing out of the holes in
her skull. Her body fell appart due
to leprosy.
Another was hung by her feet,
inside and over.
Yet another woman's body was
being shredded to pieces by
scissors made of fire.
One woman had a head of a pig
and a body of a donkey and was
given several punishments.
Another had the face of a dog, fire
was entering her body from her
posterior and come out of her
mouth and the angels were
beating her with iron rods

Fatimah then inquired her father, 'Please, tell me, what did these women do(to deserve such punishment)?'

Then the Prophet Sallallaahu alayhi wa sallam said :

'Listen my dear; The one who was hanging by her breast used to deny her husband, his righful pleasure; The one hanging by her feet used to go out of her house without her husband's permission; The one eating her own flesh used to beautify herself and show her body to men other than her husband. The one who's hands and feet were tied together and covered with snakes and scorpions never to care impurity and wasn't careful about ghusl, thus taking her prayer lightly; The deaf, blind, and dumb, used to bear children through adultery but claim the children belonged to her husband;The one whose body was being cut by scissors made of fire never observed hijab in front of non mahrem men. The one whose body was burned and who was eating her own intestines

Tammy Schaefer
T

whats wrong in it... everything is in placed well. if you feel you go to hell and afraid of punishment than different story.

Javala Rhoades 3 years

whats wrong bro..........

Muhammed David 3 years

Prophet also told situation of men in Hell but these are omitted deliberately and only stories of prostitute women are mentioned in your text which are mostly febricated.

Muhammad Chaney 3 years

If they are "fabricated", it wasn't by me.

Tammy Schaefer 3 years

Ahmed Darden ^^^ what kind of nutcase SAYS THAT GARBAGE TO HIS DAUGHTER???

Tammy Schaefer
T

ahmed do you think Mohammed had a mental problem, a drug addiction or was influenced by magic?
If so, would you still be a Muslim?

Tammy Schaefer
T

Hey bloody Islamic religion u r lots people kill ing

Venkat Sargent
V

Hmmm, interesting point... Aisha might have been 7 years old. But, that doesn't make it any better.

Tammy Schaefer
T

And Bukhari was a grown man.

Tammy Schaefer
T

Black magic, horoscope, and palmstry is prohibited in Islam.

Javala Rhoades
J

tammy

What you want your father to do encouarge

ill sex
drugs
alcohol
smoke
and Lots Sins

come on... Get some wisdom.

if you are stuck in worldly desire and temptations and wronged yourself than dont blame Islam.

Blaming Islam will not reduce your chances for Hell.

Javala Rhoades
J

Hey, I didn't write your garbage which permits slavery and pedophilia and encourages violence.
I guess you think those things are fine though?

Tammy Schaefer
T

Lockard drunkard retard

Ahmed Darden
A

Incoherent nonresponsive "comment". Are you on drugs?

Tammy Schaefer
T

black magic and wear amulets is prohibited for islam... Why don't u understand......? Do u have any mentally problem......????
Tammy Schaefer

Muhammed David
M

See whatever version of your story you narrrate here We muslims knows the benefits of Worshipping Creator of the universesi. E Islam

if you have wrong assumptions and belief and you think you have better knowledge then Muslims about Islam than plz keep that knowledge with you.

Muslims really dont care.

But whatever fake God you worship Ask that God help you in hellfire than we will see who is right and who is wrong..

That time you will ask another of worldly life for praiseing Allah almighty but will not get.

Muslim task is to deliver message what we got from our messanger. We have delivered to you.

thats all.

its your free will to choose goodI. E Islam or bad polythism.

Javala Rhoades
J

But she actually has no knowledge of islam..
Someone who cannot recognise spirituality has nothing knowledge.
tammy is another type of being who make their own meaning out live without any guidance. .
Only believes in fantasies of her brains and inconclusive scientists. .
You cannot explain islam to no one, so long as you never been a Muslim, you can't explain anything to conform to contex, you cannot. .!

Lamin Darnell
L